Sunday, April 22, 2012

Perushim

A we read in partners about the Perushim on the story of Yaakov and Esav, it said that while the babies were in the stomach, one kept kicking when they were near an unholy place( Esav) and one kept kicking when they were near a synagogue.  We also learned about Esav being a hunter, where the perush then says that he was a very deceitful, tricky and harsh person) while Yaakov was a tentdweller, where the perush said that he was learning Torah all day being holy and good.
Mrs Perl then told us in class that these explanations are simply Perushim trying to give us insight, but might not be correct.

This made me think about the idea of perushim. I think that sometimes they can be perceived as negative since they paint for you a picture that you can never forget and you end up seeing the people in the Torah as the Perushim explained them. For example, all my life, while i was thinking of Esav, I saw him as this evil man, while Yaakov seemed to me like the person son, learning Torah and being good.

Yaakov also did tricky things, like taking advantage of Esav when he was hungry, or posing as Esav in order to get a Bracha, but since he was the Nivchar he was not judged as harshly in my opinion.

I think it is sometimes hard to decipher the Torah, but the persushim in my opinion could be very misleading.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Esav the Villain?

When we were younger, we were always taught that Yaakov is the good twin and Esev is the bad twin. Yaakov studies all day and is devoted to Hashem while Esev is a wild hunter. This is the classic story that we have learned which makes it all too simple: Yaakov is good and Esev is bad. However toay when we saw the text of the pessukim, I began to have difficulty with the classic tale that we have learned. No where in the pessukim does it state that Esev was evil or wild; he is called a man of the field, and it even says that Yitzchak loved him. Unlike the stories we were taught when we were little, Yaakov does not seem to be learning all day or intensely dedicated to Hashem. He is only described as an Ish Tam who sat in his tent. How did this show that he was a serious learner and therefore making him the good twin? Furthermore, one can even see Yaakov as the "evil" one in these pessukim. He seems to be trying to deceive Esev in order to take the Bechorah, and he seemingly takes advantage of Esev's fatigue from the field and his hunger. Where do these ideas that Esev was evil came from? How can we say that Esev was the bad one when it does not seem to say explicitly in the pessukim that Esev ever did anything wrong? The midrashim that discuss Esev seem to present a conflict to the actual text of the pessukim.
hello my dear fellow classmates,
So yesterday we learned about Yitchaks relationship with his bride Rivkah. Rivkah is one of our mothers taht we are supposed to look up to. However,when Rivkah first met her future husband she actually fell off her camel and covered herself up with her scarf because she felt so inferior to him and his great connection with Hashem since she saw him pray. Clearly, Rivkah has some severe self-esteem issues and thinks that shes inferior to her man. Is this a healthy way for women to view themselves? Should we really look up to her as a role model and also feel so inferior to our husbands? I think that she should have been confident. Although she may perhaps be a little behind with her spiritual connection with Hashem she should have been optimistic and confident that she will also achieve this. She shouldnt feel inferior and defeated. Thats not a quality i would want to look up to. What do you guys think?

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

hello my dear fellow classmates,
so basically we learned about the akedah. Its very interesting because its all so very focused on avrahams relationship with God. We ask all these questions about gods motif and whether he was testing Avraham. We also ask a lot of questions about avraham and whether he passed gods test. The questions about god and avraham go on and on. Even sarah has a bit of a role in the next parsha since she dies and the midrash says that she found out about her husband sacrificing her only son whom she waited for years to have. Who is missing here? The lovely son Yitzchak! I always wondered how he felt about this entire situation and there is not a word mentioned about him and his feelings. Did he know something was up? didnt he get suspicious? wasnt he super afraid if he did know his own father was going to kill him!?!?! Personally, i think that by the end of the little trip that avraham and yitchak took, yitchak knew taht something was going on with Avraham. I wonder if he knew but simply accepted his fate. I wonder why nothing is mentiones about Yitzchak. why do you think that is?

Sunday, April 1, 2012

Conflicting Ideals

As many of you know I am a big fan of Rabbi Leibtag so I decided to read the article Mrs. Perl handed out to us after class on Thursday. I came out with some very interesting insights. I would love to share one of them with you.
You can look at the akeida as a conflict between two ideals. Natural morality is one ideal that we have talked about extensively throughout Sefer Bereishit. However, there is nothing more despicable to man's natural instinct than killing someone-especially your own son! On the other hand, from the perspective of man's relationship with G-d, there is nothing greater than the fulfillment of a divine command. In an ideal world, these two ideals should never conflict. How can G-d command us to do something that is immoral? However, in the REAL WORLD individuals often face situations where they are torn between conscience and religion. I think the Akeida can be seen as something that is kind of over our heads. When we were learning it in class, I did not see how it related to my life whatsoever. It was just giving me more insight into Avraham's exemplary character that I would never be able to live up to. However, after I read the article, I realized how the akeida can be seen as a very relatable story to our lives. We also go through these inner conflicts on a daily basis. Obviously, we are not asked to kill people, but we are faced with challenges and pressures. We have to be open to new situations and think of what we are really doing. This story also shows that not everything in life will seem or be 'ideal.' The ideal is something very difficult to achieve and even Avraham was faced with challenges to the ideal. Also, I think it is cool how the Torah gives us a real world situation. G-d understands that the real world is certainly different from the ideal world. This makes me feel good because it shows that G-d really does understand our struggles and doesn't think achieving the ideal is a 'piece of cake.'

Is God Meant to be Involved?

As we learned the mind boggling story of the Akeida, a huge question came up: Is there a system of morality and ethics independent of God, or is morality established only because God said so? This question was truly important to recognize because we learned that Avraham was willing to go everything he believed in to follow the word of God. We already knew that Avraham was a man who represented morality and ethics and Yirat Elokim. According to Soren Kirkegard, the Theologian, if God tells us to do something, we have to do it. Because God is moral and ethical. He wouldn't actually make us go through with such a thing like the Akeida because He knows that it's not right. This proves that morals and ethics stem from God. This was the biggest test to Avraham so far, and we must recognize how important God's decision was. If God was not moral, He might have let Avraham go through with the Akeida, destroying His promise of Zerah. However, we can see that this was not the truth. Avraham was willing to give up everything for God because he truly trusted in Him, and God realized that. He would never leave Avraham, the man who was meant to spread Ethical Monotheism and recognized God first, and ruin the Brit that they made together.

Poor Sarah

Imagine being an extremely old lady, and hoping all of your life that you are going to have a kid. One day, you are told by G-d that you are going to have a son and your heart is full of joy. Then a few years later, your husband disappears with your beloved child, off to do some sort of service to G-d. You continue on your usual schedule, unaware of what is really going on. Then a day or so later, someone tells you that your husband killed your son, sacrificing him to G-d.


Your heart sputters, stops, and you die. Isn't that awful?


If the midrash that says Sarah died because she thought Avraham had actually killed Yitzchak is true, that might be one of the saddest stories ever. And poor Avraham and Yitzchak, returning home to find Sarah dead.


(other opinions say that Sarah died after this whole story, and its simply the next important thing mentioned)